[WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity
Links: home · search · speed test · login · more ·

 
Links: Reply New Topic
Forums » Computing Clubs » Team Discovery » [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity
page: 1 · 2 · 3
HiVolt @ 16th Sep 01:23PM:
[WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

I've got a new 8 Core 2.8 Xeon Mac Pro here at work for a week or so now. Of course I loaded BOINC on it, and I expected it to crunch like a horse... However, something's not right...

Whenever I start Boinc, the CPU usage spikes to full on all 8 cores, but 5 seconds later it drops and settles to 84-85%. I've deleted, reinstalled BOINC, and it continues to do this. The work units take a very long time per core. There is no other process eating up any CPU time. I have another Mac Pro except it'a 4-core, and it purrs along fine at full cpu load.

Attached are some screenshots.

Any help would be appreciated.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,


Usage when first started
 

Usage after 5 seconds running
 
Click for full size
How long it takes per WU

CPU Benchmark
Click for full size
Machine Specs
reply
lilhurricane @ 16th Sep 01:45PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

I'd like to say maybe the project assumes you have a strong beast of a computer & so is sending you the hardest work units to find cures...but I'm sure that's not it :D

I'm not familiar w/ Macs so I can't help..maybe we have a member that uses one that can assist?

Congrats on your new machine, Martin :)
I'm sure there's a reason & you'll find it.

... can always ask at WCG forums as well (in Boinc Support), if no one here figures it out

»www.worldcommunitygrid.org/forum···forum=83

Edit: maybe ajeb can help?
reply
Ray422 @ 16th Sep 02:00PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Sounds like some kinda throttling, yes?

Just some food for thought...

Does the cpu speed reduce simultaneously with the cpu percentage? Any change in temperature? Any change in multiplier?
--Disable intel speedstep?

I know nothing about a mac, does it have an internal bios throttle like...
Biostar has....cool & quiet
Gigabyte has....C1e (enhanced halt)
Asus has....Same, I think (I would have to look)

I think TD member Ajeb has that same machine, perhaps he can help?

EDIT: Another thought. Could that machine have defaulted to a boinc setting that allows a lesser cpu percentage. I have had that happen to me before. You might check the maximum CPU percentage usage setting in wcg/boinc?
--
Things I like - Team Discovery - Quads©3.4ghz - Strawberry Ice cream


reply
HiVolt @ 16th Sep 02:20PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

The Mac has no configurable options like PC boards do... I have done a video encoding test and all 8 cores are fully utilized, so it's not something related to the machine.

I have checked BOINC throttling in the options, and it's set to use 100% cpu and all the processor cores.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
HiVolt @ 16th Sep 02:23PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

I've PM'd ajeb, hopefully he has a couple of minutes to take a look.

Thanks!
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
Dersgniw @ 16th Sep 02:53PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by HiVolt :

I have checked BOINC throttling in the options, and it's set to use 100% cpu and all the processor cores.
Checked it on the client options (not the website), right?
--
I Smell Cures! -- Our Hope

reply
HiVolt @ 16th Sep 03:31PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by Dersgniw :

said by HiVolt :

I have checked BOINC throttling in the options, and it's set to use 100% cpu and all the processor cores.
Checked it on the client options (not the website), right?
Yep! I'm somehow thinking the BOINC version for Mac is not that 8-core friendly... on the 4-core Mac running the exact same OS it works perfectly.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
glennaxl @ 16th Sep 03:51PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Have you checked this?
System Prefs
->Energy Saver
->Options
->Processor Performance

It should be set to "Highest".
reply
HiVolt @ 16th Sep 07:46PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by glennaxl :

Have you checked this?
System Prefs
->Energy Saver
->Options
->Processor Performance

It should be set to "Highest".
Pretty sure I did, but I don't think there is such an option on a Mac Pro, only on the laptops or imacs/minis.

I'll double check tomorrow though.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
ajeb @ 17th Sep 10:54AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Hey,
I've had my MAC PRO for about a month.

I'm running near 100% on all eight cores.

Check your energy saving panel. WCG runs at a very low priority. Just running BOINC in not enough to keep the computer from going to sleep, so make sure the computer is in "never" going to sleep and uncheck "Put hard drives to sleep.."

The hard drive thing was slowing me down when I started up.

I'm also running a different version of BOINC than you. I'm still on 5.10.45, I always wait a bit to upgrade to make sure the bugs are worked out.

Hope that helps. FYI..Getting about a 4300 RAC on the machine and that spec is still climbing.
reply
lilhurricane @ 17th Sep 11:25AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Great suggestions everyone!

And thanks glennaxl & ajeb :)

..your "things to check" on Macs are now added to our FAQ

»Team Discovery WCG BOINC FAQ »[Macs] How to Make Sure You're Running at Peak Efficiency

Edit: Let me know if there's anything else
reply
HiVolt @ 17th Sep 11:55AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Thanks... I already had the sleep settings disabled, and it doesn't seem to make a difference if they are on or off here.

Anyway, I just ran Activity Monitor and it seems that at the exact time the CPU load drops to from 100 to 85, the System percentage goes up. I dont know what that means though.

Attached is the graph. Green is User %, Red is System %.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
Dogfather @ 17th Sep 12:29PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

I'm assuming you've shown yourself "all processes" and not just "my processes" to see if something else is taking up the other 15%.

Also what happens if you open a 9th crunching instance (if you can do such a thing)?

There is also uncertainty principle in monitoring this usage but it shouldn't be anywhere near 15%. In my quad activity monitor for example takes 1.5% typically.
reply
ajeb @ 17th Sep 01:08PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Skeedatl is right...that 15% is going somewhere into the system. You should be able to find in all processes. There was a huge system update just released..is it downloading in background? Though I can't see that taking up that much cpu.
reply
HiVolt @ 17th Sep 02:48PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

This happened before the 10.5.5 also. I have looked under All Processes, and I don't see it. Here's a screenshot.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
HiVolt @ 17th Sep 02:52PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

And here's output from "top" in terminal.


--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
bbarrera @ 17th Sep 03:15PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Next time run "top -o cpu" to sort highest CPU processes first.

Might want to check the 'nice' level of BOINC client and renice if possible. I've never understood the Mac OS X process scheduler, and there is a website with some good info (believe it is Amit Singh of Google).
reply
HiVolt @ 17th Sep 04:42PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by bbarrera :

Might want to check the 'nice' level of BOINC client and renice if possible. I've never understood the Mac OS X process scheduler, and there is a website with some good info (believe it is Amit Singh of Google).
Can you explain how do I go about doing that?
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
Dogfather @ 17th Sep 04:54PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

»www.macosxhints.com/article.php?···85034927

I've also see a few utilities in my Google search like BeNicer »www.versiontracker.com/dyn/morei···sx/16534 that claim to make the process a bit quicker.

EDIT - Just toyed with BeNicer and it may not like Leo...I get some errors and VT showed it only supported Tiger and earlier.
reply
ajeb @ 17th Sep 08:53PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

This can't be this hard...lol.

I'm running 99.3% to 100% on all eight cores. My process list looks the same as yours. The only thing seems to be that I'm using an older version of BOINC.
reply
HiVolt @ 17th Sep 09:01PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by ajeb :

This can't be this hard...lol.

I'm running 99.3% to 100% on all eight cores. My process list looks the same as yours. The only thing seems to be that I'm using an older version of BOINC.
I was running the same version of BOINC before, it was doing the same thing, so I downloaded the latest...

Now, I've been thinking a bit... When I got this new 8-Core Mac Pro, I was upgrading my main workstation from a 4-Core Mac Pro that was moved to another part of the office... Now, All I did was move the hard drive over, it booted right up and I didn't think anything of it. Everything else has been working fine.

Could the Kernel or something else not be handling the 8-cores properly because of this, and not letting a low priority process like BOINC access 100% of the cores when the system is idle?

Could an archive & install from the DVD's that came with the 8-Core (10.5.4) do the trick perhaps?
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
Dogfather @ 17th Sep 11:14PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Try downloading the combo update for 10.5.5 which just came out yesterday. Perhaps there will be some magic in there for ya.
reply
ajeb @ 18th Sep 02:33AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Your using all cores so the system knows they're there. I can't see why the kernel would be written to handle them all.

How about the EFI firmware update?

»support.apple.com/kb/HT1237

Repair permission?

»www.macworld.com/article/52220/2···ons.html

Just throwing out things now...lol.

I've been reading message boards for other projects using MAC and compiled a list of the stupid things.

Are you using local preferences or web preferences? Things seem to run better for most with setting the preferences on the website of the project not locally. I set that up using the custom option of device profile on the WCG website. I have two profiles, one for my MAC, the other for my PCs. I found that Protein folding took forever to run and blocked it running on the MAC.

Screen saver set to never?
Run always in activity pull down?

I'll keep looking.
reply
jwersan @ 18th Sep 12:14PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

The MAC OS is based on UNIX, UNIX has an automatic process that will "nice" down any long running processes to stop them from taking over all processing, thus starving out other processes.

By "nice" I mean that the system will assign a lower priority to the process.

In UNIX all you would have to do is re-nice the process to a -1 and it would be ignored by the system.

Since I am NOT familiar with the MAC OS, I have no clue how you might change the process priority...

I hope this helps...
--
RIAA/MPAA... Bite me!!!!
In constant search for intelligent life on Earth!

reply
HiVolt @ 18th Sep 12:16PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

What i'll do when I have some free time is to install a fresh OS copy on a spare hard drive... I have a feeling it's got something to do with me just transferring the hard drive from the old Mac Pro.
--
,,!,,('-'),,!,,

reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 10:35AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Well, I had some free time today at work so I installed a clean copy of Leopard 10.5.4 (that came with the new Mac Pro). After installation, the first thing I did was Install Boinc...

After running the test benchmarks at 100% on all 8 cores, once all 8 work units of HCC populated the spots, it dropped down from 100% to 85%.

I'm at a loss for words. Is this beast of a machine simply not cut out for crunching? I don't get it...

Edit: I also have XP Pro installed on this machine, and I just rebooted into it and installed Boinc, and it's happily crunching on all 8 cores. WTF is wrong with the Mac version?
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
Dersgniw @ 23rd Sep 11:42AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Like glennaxl suggested, all a search turns up for me is:

System Prefs
->Energy Saver
->Options
->Processor Performance

What happens when you set BOINC to only use 85%? What about 50%? What happens when you tell it to only use 4 cores?
--
I Smell Cures! -- Our Hope

reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 11:46AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by Dersgniw :

Like glennaxl suggested, all a search turns up for me is:

System Prefs
->Energy Saver
->Options
->Processor Performance

What happens when you set BOINC to only use 85%? What about 50%? What happens when you tell it to only use 4 cores?
There is no processor performance settings on the Mac Pro in the Energy Saver preferences.

When I set only 4 cores to crunch, they operate at 96%. When I set the cores to operate at 50%, they operate at 43%.

I tried both the 5.10.45 client from WCG site as well as the latest 6.2.18 from Boinc site directly. Both behave identical.
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
Dersgniw @ 23rd Sep 11:56AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Have you tried HPF2 or any other project just to see if it's specifically the HCC project?
reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 12:27PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by Dersgniw :

Have you tried HPF2 or any other project just to see if it's specifically the HCC project?
Good idea, I tried creating a profile with HPF2 only and assigned it to the machine. I reset the project and it only downloaded HCC WU's.

Does it take some time to kick in?
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
Dersgniw @ 23rd Sep 12:36PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

You'd have to abort or suspend your WU's then get an update.
reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 12:42PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by Dersgniw :

You'd have to abort or suspend your WU's then get an update.
I reset the project, it cleared & downloaded new ones... isnt that the same thing?
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 12:55PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Well I'll be a monkey's uncle! It's HCC that's screwy on this Mac. Once HPF2's loaded up they are crunching at full capacity!

Thanks a lot for the suggestion, Brian!!! I would never have guessed it.
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
lilhurricane @ 23rd Sep 01:58PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by HiVolt :

Well I'll be a JoJo's uncle! It's HCC that's screwy on this Mac. Once HPF2's loaded up they are crunching at full capacity!

Neat-o (I think) :hmm: :D

Well..we are both projects, Martin...so w00t :D

»Team Discovery WCG BOINC FAQ »HPF2, Help Conquer Cancer? Which one Should I Choose?
--
~Safe Hex~ Team Discovery ~ Project Hope ~ Like A Hurricane~

reply
Dersgniw @ 23rd Sep 01:58PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

You should post a link to this at the HCC forum - »www.worldcommunitygrid.org/forum···orum=301 - if you don't want to, I can.
--
I Smell Cures! -- Our Hope

reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 02:25PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

If you can post it there Brian that would be great. I don't have an account there.
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
lilhurricane @ 23rd Sep 02:28PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by HiVolt :

I don't have an account there.
*AHEM :P :D

»Team Discovery WCG BOINC FAQ »Signatures & How To Help Spread the Word
reply
Dersgniw @ 23rd Sep 03:59PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

»www.worldcommunitygrid.org/forum···ad=21979
reply
HiVolt @ 23rd Sep 05:48PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

said by lilhurricane :

said by HiVolt :

I don't have an account there.
*AHEM :P :D
My bad, I had an idiot moment there... I just realized that by having an account for crunching on WCG, it's also for their forums. :D

I replied to the thread Brian, thanks!
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply
ajeb @ 27th Sep 08:53AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Posting here for those following this thread as well as on WCG forum.

I switched over to all HCC units and was able to duplicate the 85% problem on my Mac Pro.
reply
lilhurricane @ 27th Sep 11:58AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Hmm.. I'd not checked back there in a bit.
Thanks Ajeb.

Off to look now. Hoping they are going to be addressing that?
reply
Dersgniw @ 28th Sep 08:32PM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

You would think they would have a slew of 8 core Xeon Macs beta testing this stuff. :) Thanks for following up.
--
I Smell Cures! -- Our Hope

reply
HiVolt @ 29th Sep 09:08AM:
Re: [WCG] 8 Core Xeon not crunching at full capacity

Thanks for your testing, at least now we know it's HCC that's just not efficient to run on 8-core Macs. What a waste.

Sadly from the responses in the WCG forums they don't really know how to fix it and just suggest running other projects. Oh well, my 8-Core Mac Pro has been happily crunching HPF2's.
--
GO LEAFS GO!

reply

Thank you for using lo-fi dslreports.com - report bugs
© 99-2008 silver matrix LLC